Wednesday, November 16, 2011

so you want to be a writer? By Charles Bukowski

if it doesn't come bursting out of you

in spite of everything,

don't do it.

unless it comes unasked out of your

heart and your mind and your mouth

and your gut,

don't do it.

if you have to sit for hours

staring at your computer screen

or hunched over your

typewriter

searching for words,

don't do it.

if you're doing it for money or

fame,

don't do it.

if you're doing it because you want

women in your bed,

don't do it.

if you have to sit there and

rewrite it again and again,

don't do it.

if it's hard work just thinking about doing it,

don't do it.

if you're trying to write like somebody

else,

forget about it.

if you have to wait for it to roar out of

you,

then wait patiently.

if it never does roar out of you,

do something else.

if you first have to read it to your wife

or your girlfriend or your boyfriend

or your parents or to anybody at all,

you're not ready.

don't be like so many writers,

don't be like so many thousands of

people who call themselves writers,

don't be dull and boring and

pretentious, don't be consumed with self-

love.

the libraries of the world have

yawned themselves to

sleep

over your kind.

don't add to that.

don't do it.

unless it comes out of

your soul like a rocket,

unless being still would

drive you to madness or

suicide or murder,

don't do it.

unless the sun inside you is

burning your gut,

don't do it.


when it is truly time,

and if you have been chosen,

it will do it by

itself and it will keep on doing it

until you die or it dies in you.

there is no other way.

and there never was.

Our thoughts:

This poem doesn't just speak about writing but about anything you pursue in your lifetime. If you don't have the drive and compassion to do something then don't do it. When you go out into the world put everything you have into the task. Always put 100% effort into everything you do; never do anything in life because you have to, do it because you want too! In one stanza the author says "the libraries of the world have yawned themselves to sleep over your kind." The author implies that people are always trying to be someone else, not just in writing but in life too. Don't be like everybody else. Make a name for yourself and be unique, something this generation is lacking. The author also suggests that everyone should have confidence in what they have done and accomplished. If you have to ask someone if you look good or this sentence sounds alright, your not to be a writer or an adult for that matter. To succeed as a writer and as a person in the world, have confidence in what you do, be unique, and always give your all. Following these guidelines will make you a successful person and author according to Charles Bukowski. -Andy Bishop

In this poem, the author repeats the phrase "don't do it" to make it predictable for the readers as they read through the poem. The readers can tell when this phrase will come up because the author created a pattern of "If A, then B," A being the reasons to write or the outcomes of writing and B being the phrase "don't do it." Then about two-thirds of the way down, the author breaks the pattern. This catches the readers attention because there is a sudden change in the way that the poem flows. Then it goes back to the original pattern after two stanzas. The last portion of the poem finally tells the readers when it is appropriate to write. -Rachel Fatica

This poem is a very romanticized declaration and guidelines about how to be a proper writer. Bukowski is not only giving guidelines on writing, but guidelines on life too. If it doesn’t come easy or it doesn’t feel right, don’t do it. He continues the poem with these sorts of proclamations about writing and life in general. It is very sugar coated however and suggests that writing and life is going to be easy, when that is not always the case. He has many good points, however, because when writing, if it is forced, it will never be as good as of words that flow easily and freely. Overall, his advice is sound, but at times can be taken as overly simplistic. -Alex Lewis

This is a very deep and interesting poem. I agree with most of the statements of the writer, such as when he says that you shouldn’t write if you are trying to be someone else, or if you are doing it just to get money or women. I half-heartedly agree with him as he talks about not writing, unless it is basically perfect and you were meant to do it. I think that all writers have that point where they aren’t sure about something, or they get stuck and need some time to work on it. If your writing doesn’t just pour out of you in a perfect fashion as this poet says, it isn’t the end of the world. There are writers that fit the styles of all different kinds of readers in this world and these readers are constantly looking for more material to add to their list of things to read. I am all for these writers to do their best and try to do it for the readers, themselves, and to better the world of literature. NOT to get women. -Josh Myers

8 comments:

Shelby Caldwell said...

I believe this was a good quote to end the class with. Its the last blog project and it leaves us with such a good message. You must have committment and passion to pursue something. That can be writing in this case or anything like school, sports and life. Always make the best of every situation and think of the best outcome. Do things because you want to not because you have to. Be true to yourself. Also when its time you will know its time.

Kristen Cuevas said...

The idea of free thinking is exactly how everybody should approach writing. You're own thoughts are what defines you. If there is any hesitation of what your answer might be because it is different, vague, boring, new, or stupid, then you should take a break. Writing should come from the heart; it should reflect who you are, not what anybody would want to read. This also relates to other aspects of life. It's important to do things that you are passionate about. It's difficult to be productive and do tasks well if you do not enjoy them. A paycheck or a letter grade is a dull motivation. "When you enjoy what you do, work becomes play."

jdru said...

In the beginning before a good writer is truly published, he/she must work all on his own without a developed group of editors perfecting the work and giving advice. Once the work is published and succesful, then the money comes flowing for the fancy editors. But then the writer's block may come as want for the additional writing comes.

I don't agree with the poem though because of these times today because of how desperate we are to make an extra buck, and especially as we have the rappers of today rhyming in order to entertain and they "just wanna be famous" not neccasarily rich, but of course the money is a definite plus.

Spencer said...

Although this quote obviously relates to writing, it seems that it can be related to anything in life. It seems to say that unless you have a passion for something, that you shouldn't waste your time; not only for writing but for any aspect of life. If something feels like work, you feel the need for others' approval, or you are doing it for glory, you shouldn't do it. And when something "chooses" you it is something that you truly enjoy and that drive will stay with you "until you die or it dies in you."

Josh Myers said...

I think that everyone will think of this in a different way, with different opinions on what it means. I originally disagreed with this poem, saying that every reader has a specific genre or topic that they enjoy to read. For them to get what they want in a read, someone has to write it. I think that even if you aren't perfect at writing, or if you do it for other reasons than to write, you should still do it. I also have a different opinion on this poem such as having passion when you do anything, not just writing. I think for most things that you do in life, you need to be passionate and ENJOY your activity. I think that having a career for instance, for the money, is understandable. BUT I think that you should ultimately try and find a career that you enjoy most. I think that this poem has some emphasis on finding something you have a passion in.

Anonymous said...

I really liked the simplicity of this poem. The message was laid out clearly in black and white standards. Poems are usually riddled with complicated metaphors and confusing diction, but this poem let the message speak for itself. The speaker of the poem was firm but fair; it felt as though they were giving advice to a friend. Liking what you do is the most important factor in life choices, and this poem captures that.

Zoe Allegretti said...

To begin, I immediately related this poem to life as oppose to simply writing. Based on this, I enjoy the simplicity of this poem and how it straight up tells you what to do because I personally find myself to be a very indecisive individual. However, as much as I wish it were, life just is not as simple as if you don't feel like it, don't do it. In high school and college thus far, I am yet to ever want to do homework and or able to sit down and understand a math or chemistry problem and/or concept right away. So in these cases, the answers are not "bursting out of me" but I still need to persevere and get the work done and done to the best of my ability. Lastly, I would personally feel more satisfied with my success knowing that it came from hard work as oppose to the solutions just "coming to me."

Maxim said...

I'd rather say "Don't publish". Some writings are not good enough to correctly appeal to the reader. If you go to a bookstore and grab the hundredth book, it will probably be a boring mediocre story. That is sad. However, it doesn't mean we should ban it. Instead, we can just encourage publishers to be more selective.